Claim your business to update business information, customize this listing, and more!
Mateo's Tomato Pie & Restaurant Giftly
A beautiful gift card alternative for Mateo's Tomato Pie & Restaurant
Gift Amount
Gift Design
100% satisfaction guarantee
Gift Tips
- Try the Trenton-style tomato pie if you want the restaurant’s signature pizza experience.
- Order a cheesesteak on a seeded roll for a hearty, well-made sandwich option.
- The white pizza with broccoli and extra garlic is a strong pick for something a little different.
- Ask about the chicken francese or vodka rigatoni when planning a larger meal or catering order.
- If you like a classic slice, the grandma pie and plain pie are both solid choices.
Click here to send a gift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to use it at Mateo's Tomato Pie & Restaurant.
Mateo's Tomato Pie & Restaurant is a pizza spot in Hainesport, NJ 08036. It is known for its straightforward approach to Italian-American comfort food and serves guests looking for a casual place to eat in town.
- Ambiance: Mateo's Tomato Pie & Restaurant in Hainesport, NJ offers a clean, casual setting that feels welcoming for families and everyday meals.
- Cuisine: The menu focuses on pizza, including Trenton-style tomato pie, along with cheesesteaks, subs, Italian entrees, and classic sides.
- Highlights: Guests can find a friendly team, quick service, and a menu that works well for both dine-in meals and takeout.
The restaurant is a good fit for people who want a solid meal without a lot of fuss. Its tomato pie stands out as a signature item, and the menu also includes several sandwich and pasta choices for different tastes.
Mateo's also works well for group meals and family dinners because the portions are generous and the food travels well. It gives visitors a dependable option for pizza night, lunch, or a simple dinner stop in Hainesport.
Customer Reviews
EXCELLENT Trenton style pie.
Excellent cheesesteak. Very thick-toasted garlic bread-lots of toppings.
A hidden gem!!! read review
Solid pizza for sure. We stopped on our way from NYC to DC for the pizza and was not disappointed. Tge pizza is REALLY good. The room could certainly use... read review
Finally got to try Pizza from here after seeing all the reviews. I'm not a tomato pie fan, but I figured I'd try the other pizzas and toppings. The lump... read review
Harriett T.
12/13/2025
12/13/2025nycParkie K.
03/24/2026
03/24/2026Steve J.09/10/2025
09/10/2025Great Alternatives
Buy a Gift & Greeting Card for Lillo's Tomato Pies: Lillo's Tomato Pies in Hainesport offers a delectable menu of mouthwatering tomato pies that will transport you to pizza paradise.
Gift $100 for Pandora Diner: Pandora Diner in Hainesport offers a delightful dining experience with a diverse menu that caters to all tastes, making it a perfect gift for those who appreciate good food in a cozy atmosphere.
The Giftly Advantage
With Giftly you strike a perfect balance, the thoughtfulness of a Mateo's Tomato Pie & Restaurant gift card with the flexibility of money.
- Easy to buy online. Have it delivered now or later
- Send it with a personalized greeting card
- 3 easy ways for your recipient to redeem the gift
100% satisfaction guaranteed
No wasted balance
Easy to customize
How it works
- You customize a giftGift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to use it at Mateo's Tomato Pie & Restaurant. Delivered in a personalized greeting card.
- They receive the giftGifts can be sent by email, SMS*, mail or you can print it yourself.
- They enjoy it!They redeem the gift on our website and choose to deposit the funds in their bank account, Paypal account or to have a Visa / Mastercard Gift Card mailed to them.
Top Related Gifts
More Nearby Businesses
Aunt Selma's Candy
1459 Rte 38 W, Hainesport, NJ
2.9(11)•
$$ • Chocolatiers & Shops
Pirones Restaurant & Catering
1351 NJ-38, Hainesport, NJ
Italian
Aziza's Restaurant
2825 Marne Hwy, Hainesport, NJ
4.1(30)•
$ • Restaurants
Passariello's Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen - Moorestown
13 W Main St, Moorestown, NJ
3.6(214)•
$$ • Pizza
Tarantella Ristorante
128 NJ-70, Medford, NJ
3.8(268)•
$$ • Pizza
Angelo's II Pizza Ristorante
271 Masonville Rd, Mount Laurel, NJ
4.1(27)•
$$ • Pizza
Tacconelli’s Pizzeria
164 Haddon Ave, Haddon Township, NJ
3.9(54)•
Pizza
Pat's Pizzeria
1603 Rt 38, Lumberton, NJ
2.9(9)•
$ • Pizza
Sal & Joe's Pizza & Restaurant
300 S Lenola Rd, Maple Shade, NJ
4.4(189)•
$$ • Pizza
Pizza 541
1817 Mt Holly Rd, Burlington, NJ
3.8(48)•
Pizza
Michaelangelo's Pizza Restaurant
1334 Brace Rd, Cherry Hill, NJ
3.8(118)•
$$ • Pizza
Old Village Pizza
897 Rancocas Rd, Westampton Township, NJ
3.4(13)•
Pizza
Gaetano's Pizzeria
434 Pine St, Mount Holly, NJ
2.6(19)•
Pizza
La Piazza
11 Church St, Allentown, NJ
4.1(263)•
$$ • Pizza
Johnny Longhots Steaks
1508 Rte 38, Hainesport, NJ
4.2(62)•
Sandwiches
Johnny Longhots - Hainesport
1508 Rte 38, Hainesport, NJ
4.2(62)•
Sandwiches
Downtown Pizza and Italian Grill
35 High St, Mount Holly, NJ
4.1(238)•
$ • Pizza
Little Shop of Pizza
723 Main St, Lumberton, NJ
3.8(38)•
$ • Pizza
La Vita Pizzeria
12 High St, Mount Holly, NJ
3.6(91)•
$$ • Pizza
Casa Nostra
320 Evesboro Medford Rd, Marlton, NJ
3.9(86)•
Pizza
Pepperoni's Pizza & Ice Cream
71 Springside Rd, Westampton, NJ
3.3(52)•
$ • Pizza
Crust N Fire
439 Larchmont Blvd, Mount Laurel Township, NJ
3.7(136)•
Pizza
Barclay Pies
450 Marlton Pike E, Cherry Hill, NJ
4.8(20)•
Pizza
Tony Soprano's Pizza
1599 Route 38, Lumberton, NJ
3.7(3)•
$ • Pizza
Stella Pizza & Restaurant
505 Haddon Ave, Collingswood, NJ
3.5(110)•
$$ • Pizza
Brooklyn Original Pizzeria
908 W Kings Hwy, Haddon Heights, NJ
4.4(198)•
Pizza
Kate & Al's Pizza
2919 Rte 206, Columbus, NJ
4.3(110)•
$ • Pizza
East Ridge Pizzeria Restaurant
621 Beverly Rancocas Rd, Willingboro, NJ
3.8(47)•
$$ • Pizza
Dunleavy's Restaurant & Cocktail Lounge
1440 Rt 38, Hainesport, NJ
3.9(135)•
$$ • Irish
Tavern & Table
2303 Marne Hwy, Hainesport, NJ
4.3(13)•
American
Sal's Pizzeria
509 High St, Mount Holly, NJ
3.4(49)•
$$ • Pizza
Riviera Pizza
212 Tuckerton Rd, Medford, NJ
4.4(40)•
$$ • Pizza
Villa Rosa Restaurant & Pizzeria
38 Us-130, Burlington, NJ
3.9(75)•
$ • Pizza
Ragazzi Pizza & Restaurant
44 W Rt 70, Marlton, NJ
3.8(94)•
$$ • Pizza
Taqueria Los Cuates
1599 NJ 38 W, Lumberton, NJ
3.8(4)•
Pizza
Pats Select Pizza & Grill
201 NJ 73, Marlton, NJ
3.2(119)•
$$ • Pizza
Johnny Longhots
752 W Rte 70, Marlton, NJ
3.6(129)•
$$ • Pizza
Palermo's
674 Rte 206 S, Bordentown, NJ
4.0(253)•
$$ • Pizza
Pizza Barn
2670 Rt 206, Mount Holly, NJ
3.3(36)•
$$ • Pizza
Back Door Pizza
1438 Marlton Pike E, Cherry Hill, NJ
4.2(86)•
Pizza
Bricco Coal Fired Pizza
128 Haddon Ave, Westmont, NJ
3.8(393)•
$$ • Pizza
Villa Mannino Ristorante & Pizzeria
73 Rt 130, Bordentown, NJ
4.0(62)•
$$ • Pizza
