1. Gifts
  2. East Hampton
  3. Restaurants
  4. Nick & Toni's

Nick & Toni's Giftly

A beautiful gift card alternative for Nick & Toni's

Nick & Toni's gift card

Gift Amount

Gift Design

HolidayHoliday
A smiling sun100% satisfaction guarantee

Nick & Toni's

Yelp Rating - 3.7 stars(349)Yelp logo
(631) 324-3550
user provided Nick & Toni's photo
CategoriesItalian, Bars, Mediterranean
Location136 N Main St, East Hampton, NY
user provided Nick & Toni's photo

Gift Tips

  • Try the zucchini fritti or zucchini chips for a shareable starter that sets up the meal well.
  • Ask for recommendations from attentive servers such as Willie, Moses, Moises, or Jessy if you want help choosing dishes or drinks.
  • Order the short rib ricotta ravioli or the rigatoni dishes for a comforting pasta option that stands out.
  • Save room for dessert and consider the tartufo, olive oil cake, or strawberry sorbet for a sweet finish.
  • If you enjoy seafood, the whole fish or tilefish are strong choices, especially with the seasonal sides.
  • If you like a well-made drink, the Meyer Lemon Cosmo and the wine list are both good options to explore.

Click here to send a gift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to use it at Nick & Toni's.

Is this your business?
Claim your business to update business information, customize this listing, and more!
Learn more about Nick & Toni's
Price$$$
AmbienceClassy
Year Established1988
Hours
Monday-Saturday: 5:30PM-10PMSunday: 5PM-10PM
Nick & Toni's photoNick & Toni's photo
Nick & Toni's map location

Nick & Toni's is a popular restaurant in East Hampton, NY 11937. It is one of the area's best-known dining spots and has built a strong reputation for stylish meals, steady service, and a menu that changes with the seasons.

  • Ambiance: Nick & Toni's offers a classy, lively dining room that feels polished without being too formal. It is a well-known East Hampton spot for a relaxed dinner that still feels special.
  • Cuisine: The menu blends Italian and Mediterranean flavors with a seasonal focus. The kitchen uses fresh ingredients, including produce from its own organic garden, and highlights wood-burning oven dishes and handmade pasta.
  • Highlights: Guests often look for the restaurant's well-known whole fish specials, thoughtful wine choices, and attentive service. The menu changes with the season, so there is usually something new to try.

The restaurant has a comfortable, energetic feel that works well for date nights, dinners with friends, or a celebratory meal. It draws people who want a place that feels classic to the Hamptons while still keeping things warm and approachable.

Its food leans on simple, well-made dishes rather than heavy presentation. With house-grown ingredients, fresh seafood, and a strong pasta selection, Nick & Toni's gives diners a dependable option for a thoughtful meal in East Hampton.

The wine and cocktail choices add to the experience, and the overall setting makes it easy to settle in for a full evening. For anyone looking for a familiar East Hampton favorite with a seasonal menu, this restaurant is an easy pick.


Customer Reviews
Ken S.
Yelp Rating - 5.0 stars08/31/2026
Excellent. Farm to table. Even tasted top soil. lol. Focaccia bread best ever had. Rest of meal and service was extraordinary. Best vodka martini chilled A... read review
Christopher B.
Yelp Rating - 3.0 stars08/13/2026
Having been to Nick & Toni's three times in the past, I believe that the service quality and atmosphere has declined since my prior visits. Our party was... read review
Doug S.
Yelp Rating - 5.0 stars08/07/2026
Went to Nick and Tony's with my girlfriend our friend and two young ladies that were very close to in Bridgehampton. We decided to revisit Nick and Tony's,... read review

Great Alternatives

Buy a Gift & Greeting Card for Cittanuova: Cittanuova in East Hampton is a vibrant and welcoming Italian restaurant that serves up delicious and authentic cuisine in a stylish and lively atmosphere.

Gift $100 for Serafina East Hampton: Serafina East Hampton is a charming Italian restaurant that invites guests to savor the authentic flavors of Italy in the heart of East Hampton.

Updated: November 12, 2026

The Giftly Advantage

With Giftly you strike a perfect balance, the thoughtfulness of a Nick & Toni's gift card with the flexibility of money.

  • Easy to buy online. Have it delivered now or later
  • Send it with a personalized greeting card
  • 3 easy ways for your recipient to redeem the gift
See a Sample Gift
A smiling sun100% satisfaction
guaranteed
A stack of coinsNo wasted balance
A set of colored gift cardsEasy to
customize

How it works

  1. You customize a gift
    Gift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to use it at Nick & Toni's. Delivered in a personalized greeting card.
  2. They receive the gift
    Gifts can be sent by email, SMS*, mail or you can print it yourself.
  3. They enjoy it!
    They redeem the gift on our website and choose to deposit the funds in their bank account, Paypal account or to have a Visa / Mastercard Gift Card mailed to them.
They can spend the money at Nick & Toni's or anywhere else they like!

Top Related Gifts

More Nearby Businesses

Help

If you have questions, need help, or want to modify, resend, or cancel a gift, please see our Support Center, where you can access an array of self-service tools and our FAQ.

For other questions or issues, please contact support@giftly.com .

Gift Disclosure

The Giftly Prepaid Gift is redeemed for money through the Giftly website. It is not issued, endorsed, or accepted by any third-party merchant (including any third-party merchant explicitly referenced in this Giftly Prepaid Gift), and is not covered by the CARD Act. Giftly Prepaid Gifts never expire and there are no inactivity fees. Please see the Giftly Prepaid Gift Agreement for the complete terms.