Buy a Michael's Frozen Custard
Gift & Greeting Card

Buy a gift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to spend it at Michael's Frozen Custard. Delivered in a customized greeting card by email, mail or printout.
Buy a gift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to spend it at Michael's Frozen Custard. Delivered in a customized greeting card by email, mail or printout.
Previous design
Anything at
Michael's Frozen Custard
Next design

Gift Design

Classic Blue card designClassic Black card designGreen Swirls card designPurple Swirls card designVintage Leaves card designArt Deco Green card designBirds Of Paradise card designTiny Hearts card designColorful Pedals card designTropical Forest card design

Gift Amount


Customer Testimonials

Michael's Frozen Custard

Yelp Rating - 3.0 stars
76 reviews onYelp logo
(608) 222-4110
Location3826 Atwood Ave Madison, WI
CategoriesIce Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Burgers

Learn more about Michael's Frozen Custard

updated: September 20, 2023
Year Established
Michael's Frozen Custard map location
Emerald S.
Yelp Rating - 5.0 stars06/01/2023
It may have been a voyage to get here but it was so worth it! There's lots of construction going on so getting here was extremely difficult but once I got... read review
Allison G.
Yelp Rating - 5.0 stars06/08/2021
Best ice cream in Madison!!! The ice cream is thick, creamy, and oh so flavorful!! I love their sundaes and Twisters. The ice cream itself is so delicious... read review
Brei N.
Yelp Rating - 1.0 stars05/06/2022
Wowowowowow this place is crazzzy expensive! $18 for TWO small custards. I got a scoop of vanilla w/pb cups and dad got a on pb cup sundae. $8 for mine and... read review

Business Description

Michael's Frozen Custard, located in Madison, WI, is an ice cream and frozen yogurt shop that has built a reputation for serving up some of the best custard in town. The shop's menu includes a wide range of frozen treats such as sundaes, twisters, and shakes.

Customers rave about the quality of the custard, which is thick, creamy, and bursting with flavor. The sundaes are a fan favorite, with customers often choosing to customize them with their favorite toppings, such as hot fudge or fresh fruit.

Despite the high quality of the custard, some customers note that the prices at Michael's Frozen Custard can be a bit on the expensive side. However, many feel that the quality of the product more than justifies the cost.

The shop's ambience is casual yet classy, making it the perfect spot for a sweet treat on a warm summer day. The friendly staff members are always on hand to help customers decide on the perfect treat, and they take pride in providing excellent customer service.

If you're in the Madison area and looking for a delicious frozen treat, Michael's Frozen Custard is not to be missed. With its top-notch custard and welcoming atmosphere, it's no wonder why this shop has become a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.

Gift Ideas for Michael's Frozen Custard

If you're looking to surprise a loved one with a sweet treat, Michael's Frozen Custard is the perfect place to turn to for a gift that's sure to please. With its wide range of frozen desserts and customizable options, there's something for everyone at this Madison gem.

For the chocolate lover in your life, consider treating them to a rich and decadent hot fudge sundae. This classic treat is made with Michael's signature custard and topped with a generous helping of warm, gooey fudge. It's the perfect indulgence for anyone with a sweet tooth.

If your recipient is more of a fruit lover, consider gifting them with a refreshing fruit smoothie. Made with fresh, seasonal fruit and Michael's creamy custard, these smoothies are a healthy yet delicious way to cool down on a hot summer day.

For a truly unique gift, why not surprise your loved one with a custom ice cream cake? Michael's Frozen Custard offers a range of cake sizes and flavors, and the staff members are happy to help you create the perfect cake for any occasion. From birthdays to graduations, an ice cream cake from Michael's is sure to be a hit.

No matter what gift you choose, you can rest assured that it will be made with the same high-quality custard that has made Michael's Frozen Custard a beloved local institution. So why not treat your loved one to a sweet surprise from this Madison favorite?

Click here to send a gift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to use it at Michael's Frozen Custard

Great Restaurant Gifts Nearby

Buy a Gift & Greeting Card for Habanero's Mexican Grill: Habanero's Mexican Grill in Madison is a vibrant and authentic dining destination that serves up mouthwatering Mexican cuisine with a flair that will transport your taste buds to the bustling streets of Mexico City.

Gift $100 for Cottage Cafe: Welcome to the delightful Cottage Cafe in Madison, a charming eatery where you can savor delectable homemade dishes in a cozy and inviting atmosphere.

Descriptions, images, reviews and other business information on this page have not been verified by Giftly or Sunrise Bank.
Is this your business?Claim your business to update business information, customize this listing, and more!

The Giftly Advantage

With Giftly you strike a perfect balance, the thoughtfulness of a Michael's Frozen Custard gift card with the flexibility of money.
  • Easy to buy online. Have it delivered now or later
  • Send it with a personalized greeting card
  • 3 easy ways for your recipient to redeem the gift
See Sample Gift
100% Satisfaction Gauranteed
No wasted balance
Easy to customize

How it works

  1. You customize a gift
    Gift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to use it at Michael's Frozen Custard. Delivered in a personalized greeting card.
  2. They receive the gift
    Gifts can be sent by email, SMS*, mail or you can print it yourself.
  3. They enjoy it!
    They redeem the gift on our website and choose to deposit the funds in their bank account, Paypal account or to have a Visa Gift Card mailed to them.
They can spend the money at Michael's Frozen Custard or anywhere else they like!

You might also consider..


If you have questions, need help, or want to modify, resend, or cancel a gift, please see our Support Center, where you can access an array of self-service tools and our FAQ.For other questions or issues, please contact

Gift Disclosure

The Giftly Prepaid Gift is redeemed for money through the Giftly website. It is not issued, endorsed, or accepted by any third-party merchant (including any third-party merchant explicitly referenced in this Giftly Prepaid Gift), and is not covered by the CARD Act. Giftly Prepaid Gifts never expire and there are no inactivity fees. Please see the Giftly Prepaid Gift Agreement for the complete terms.