Claim your business to update business information, customize this listing, and more!
Carlo's Pizzeria & Bar Giftly
A beautiful gift card alternative for Carlo's Pizzeria & Bar
Gift Amount
Gift Design
100% satisfaction guarantee
CategoriesPizza, Italian, Chicken Wings
Location295 Wawayanda Ave, Middletown, NY
Gift Tips
- Use a gift card toward catering — Carlo's does repeat catering for parties and delivers orders ready on time, making it a great choice for graduations or family gatherings.
- Try the combo meals (like Combo #1) for feeding a small group: they often include a large pizza, wings, soda and sometimes garlic knots, giving good value.
- Order pizza by the slice for a quick, filling option — slices are large and flavorful, good for lunch or a casual gift recipient who prefers grab-and-go.
- Ask for bartender-made cocktails when dining at the bar — the strawberry margarita and blood orange cosmo were called out as standout drinks made by attentive bartenders.
- Request familiar staff when possible (servers like Emily and bartenders like Megan were noted as friendly and knowledgeable) to enhance the dining experience for your gift recipient.
Click here to send a gift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to use it at Carlo's Pizzeria & Bar.
Price$$
Carlo's Pizzeria & Bar is a pizza and Italian restaurant in Middletown, NY (10940). Located in a neighborhood that's convenient for families and nearby gatherings, it blends a casual dining room with a small bar area.
- Ambiance: Bright, clean dining room with a family-friendly side and a casual bar area for watching games or enjoying cocktails.
- Cuisine: Italian and pizza-focused menu with large slices, specialty pies, wings, paninis and classic pasta dishes.
- Highlights: Off-site catering for events, generous portions, friendly service and popular signature cocktails at the bar.
The restaurant is known for its sturdy crusts and large, satisfying slices, plus a menu that covers both quick lunch options and fuller dinner plates like rigatoni and paninis. Its bar offers cocktails that pair well with the food, and several guests single out particular bartenders and servers for friendly service.
Carlo's also handles catering for events and has returned customers who use it for family celebrations. With a combination of takeout-by-the-slice, dine-in comfort and reliable catering, it works well for everyday meals and special occasions.
Customer Reviews
We're still relatively new to the area so this was our first time visiting.
The restaurant is very clean and bright.
A very sweet gentleman told us we... read review
Good pizza good salad good eggplant.
Veal parmigiana was like chewing over cooked veal or like eating a dry pork cutlet.
Clean restaurant good service but... read review
Hey all
My wife and I are still craving your delicious pizza...
We are no longer in the area but we have made your pizza the standard by which we measure... read review
Linda S.
11/26/2025
11/26/2025Steve N.
07/14/2025
07/14/2025Devere O.05/05/2024
05/05/2024Great Alternatives
Gift $100 for Franco Di Roma: Franco Di Roma, located in the vibrant town of Middletown, is a delightful Italian restaurant that offers a delectable menu filled with authentic flavors and a warm, inviting atmosphere.
Buy a Gift & Greeting Card for John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant & Pizzeria: Indulge in the mouthwatering flavors of authentic Italian cuisine at John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant & Pizzeria in Middletown, where every bite transports you to the enchanting streets of Italy.
The Giftly Advantage
With Giftly you strike a perfect balance, the thoughtfulness of a Carlo's Pizzeria & Bar gift card with the flexibility of money.
- Easy to buy online. Have it delivered now or later
- Send it with a personalized greeting card
- 3 easy ways for your recipient to redeem the gift
100% satisfaction guaranteed
No wasted balance
Easy to customize
How it works
- You customize a giftGift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to use it at Carlo's Pizzeria & Bar. Delivered in a personalized greeting card.
- They receive the giftGifts can be sent by email, SMS*, mail or you can print it yourself.
- They enjoy it!They redeem the gift on our website and choose to deposit the funds in their bank account, Paypal account or to have a Visa / Mastercard Gift Card mailed to them.
Top Related Gifts
More Nearby Businesses
Brother Bruno's Pizzeria & Restaurant
125 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY
3.4(78)•
$ • Pizza
Fuentes Wood Fired Pizza & Italian Restaurant
400 Route 211 E, Middletown, NY
3.6(21)•
Pizza
Bella Lena's Restaurant & Pizzeria
511 Rte 17M, Middletown, NY
4.8(10)•
Pizza
Yovani's Pizza
741 NY-211, Middletown, NY
3.5(4)•
Pizza
Frank's Pizza Italian Restaurant
470 Rte 211 E, Middletown, NY
3.4(115)•
$ • Italian
Cugino's
2376 Rte 6, Middletown, NY
4.3(51)•
$$ • Italian
Clemson Bros. Brewery
22 Cottage St, Middletown, NY
3.9(323)•
$$ • Breweries
Hanami Japanese Cuisine
21 W Main St, Middletown, NY
4.0(110)•
$$ • Asian Fusion
Seoul Sizzle
101 Monhagen Ave, Middletown, NY
4.7(82)•
$$ • Korean
You You Restaurant
465 Rt 211E, Middletown, NY
3.5(117)•
$$ • Chinese
Bakery Plus
383 Rt 211 E, Middletown, NY
4.5(60)•
$$ • Bakeries
Martin Liquors
130 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY
4.3(8)•
$$ • Beer, Wine & Spirits
Copperbarn Coffeebar & Eatery
368 E Main St, Middletown, NY
4.1(196)•
$$ • Coffee & Tea
Shoprite Store - 216
330 Route 211 E, Middletown, NY
3.2(13)•
$$ • Grocery
Joey's Pizza Italian Restuarant
88 Dunning Rd, Middletown, NY
3.8(120)•
$ • Pizza
Badabing Pizzeria
28 County Road 78, Middletown, NY
2.7(52)•
$ • Pizza
Cosimo's Brick Oven Ristorante & Bar
620 Rt 211 E, Middletown, NY
3.9(378)•
$$ • Pizza
Sicilian Delight
1 N Galleria Dr, Middletown, NY
3.1(9)•
Pizza
Crown Fried chicken
203 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY
3.2(14)•
Chicken Shop
Piccolo Cucina e Vino
17 North St, Middletown, NY
4.8(31)•
$$ • Coffee & Tea
Saffron
130 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY
4.1(291)•
$$ • Indian
Frontera Tacos & Tequila
340 Route 211 E, Middletown, NY
3.5(194)•
$$ • New Mexican Cuisine
Blend Smoothie and Salad Bar- Middletown
265 E Rte 211, Middletown, NY
3.9(89)•
$$ • Juice Bars & Smoothies
Yuan Fu Chinese Food
251 Highland Ave, Middletown, NY
4.1(18)•
$$ • Chinese
Go-Go Chinese & Japanese Restaurant
88-22 Dunning Rd, Middletown, NY
3.0(30)•
$$ • Chinese
Dos Amigos
540 Bloomingburg Rd, Middletown, NY
4.0(124)•
$$ • Mexican
Grand Liquor
256 Route 211 E, Middletown, NY
4.0(2)•
$$ • Beer, Wine & Spirits
Price Chopper Supermarket
511 Schutt Rd Ext, Middletown, NY
2.8(21)•
$$ • Grocery
Caputo's Pizza
36-42 James St, Middletown, NY
3.8(50)•
Pizza
Pizza Star
400 NY-211, Middletown, NY
4.5(13)•
Pizza
Pecorinos Pizzeria & Restaurant
253 Tower Dr, Middletown, NY
4.1(31)•
$$ • Pizza
Alfonso's Pizzeria & Restaurants
835 Rt 211 E, Middletown, NY
4.0(35)•
$ • Pizza
Planet Wings
171 W Main St, Middletown, NY
2.2(23)•
$$ • Chicken Wings
Ikaro
9 King St, Middletown, NY
4.3(46)•
$$ • Breakfast & Brunch
Colonial Diner
8 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY
3.3(115)•
$$ • Diners
Equilibrium Brewery
4 South St, Middletown, NY
4.3(143)•
$$ • Breweries
Americana Diner & Restaurant
420 Rt 211 E, Middletown, NY
3.1(173)•
$$ • Diners
Empire Chinese Restaurant
156 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY
2.5(32)•
$$ • Chinese
Jackie's Latin Kitchen
76 East Main St, Middletown, NY
4.5(23)•
$$ • Latin American
Zoghbys Blueberry Mountain Ice Cream
655 Rte 17M, Middletown, NY
3.8(44)•
$$ • Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
El Zapata
16 East Main St, Middletown, NY
4.4(43)•
$$ • Mexican
Asian 211 Bistro
254 Rt 211 E, Middletown, NY
4.0(133)•
$$ • Japanese
