Claim your business to update business information, customize this listing, and more!
Captain Jack's Goodtime Tavern Giftly
A beautiful gift card alternative for Captain Jack's Goodtime Tavern
Gift Amount
Gift Design
100% satisfaction guarantee
CategoriesSeafood, American, Pizza
Location8505 Greig St, Sodus Point, NY
Gift Tips
- Try the lobster pizza — it's a standout item and is available on a gluten-free crust.
- Order the lobster bisque for a rich, lobster-forward starter; many guests praise its generous lobster pieces.
- Go for the honey-battered or coconut shrimp if you want a shareable, crowd-pleasing appetizer.
- If visiting on a special night, check the live music schedule and plan to sit on the deck to enjoy waterfront views of Sodus Bay.
- Ask about the Friday prime rib special for a hearty entrée at a good value.
Click here to send a gift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to use it at Captain Jack's Goodtime Tavern.
Price$$
AmbienceCasual
Year Established2024
Captain Jack's Goodtime Tavern is a waterfront restaurant in Sodus Point, NY, sitting right on Sodus Bay. The tavern occupies a historic spot on the point and offers outdoor deck seating, a Tiki bar, and docking for boats.
- Ambiance: casual waterfront tavern with outdoor deck, Tiki bar, and live music overlooking Sodus Bay in Sodus Point.
- Cuisine: American and seafood-focused menu with items like lobster bisque, lobster pizza, wings, coconut shrimp, and prime rib specials.
- Highlights: 45 beers on tap, boat docking, onsite retail shop, and frequent live music events.
The menu blends classic American tavern fare with seafood specialties, from generous fish fry plates to lobster-forward dishes. Portions are hearty and the drink list is extensive, including an especially large selection of beers on tap.
Service leans friendly and familiar, and the owners maintain a neighborhood feel that welcomes both locals and visitors. The location and live music make it a natural choice for casual summer evenings, family celebrations, or a relaxed lunch by the water.
Customer Reviews
****UPDATED. The owner at this establishment has since private messaged me about leaving Jack's a 'terrible review." And claims since I didn't actually get... read review
Still a great place . Food is good, bartenders are great and when it's not snowing superb read review
Great service and food was delicious! #CaptJacks #soduspoint #sodusbay #lakeontario #livemusic #unsalted #@captainjacksgoodtimetavern #buzzybooth read review
Sarah G.
09/16/2025
09/16/2025Christine F.
01/05/2026
01/05/2026Paul B.09/13/2025
09/13/2025Great Alternatives
Gift $100 for The Bay Street: Discover a hidden gem in the heart of Sodus Point, where The Bay Street charms locals and visitors alike with its inviting atmosphere and delectable dishes.
Buy a Gift & Greeting Card for Tick-Toc Croc's Cafe: Tick-Toc Croc's Cafe in Sodus Point offers a charming waterfront dining experience with delicious food and a laid-back atmosphere that will make you feel right at home.
The Giftly Advantage
With Giftly you strike a perfect balance, the thoughtfulness of a Captain Jack's Goodtime Tavern gift card with the flexibility of money.
- Easy to buy online. Have it delivered now or later
- Send it with a personalized greeting card
- 3 easy ways for your recipient to redeem the gift
100% satisfaction guaranteed
No wasted balance
Easy to customize
How it works
- You customize a giftGift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to use it at Captain Jack's Goodtime Tavern. Delivered in a personalized greeting card.
- They receive the giftGifts can be sent by email, SMS*, mail or you can print it yourself.
- They enjoy it!They redeem the gift on our website and choose to deposit the funds in their bank account, Paypal account or to have a Visa / Mastercard Gift Card mailed to them.
Top Related Gifts
More Nearby Businesses
Six50
8489 Greig St, Sodus Point, NY
2.7(78)•
$$$ • American
Doug's Fish Fry
8 Jordan St, Skaneateles, NY
4.3(374)•
$$ • Seafood
Rella
181 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY
4.6(97)•
$$ • Seafood
Cheap Charlie's Restaurant
8 Elm St, Bloomfield, NY
3.3(33)•
$$ • Seafood
Seafood Express
95 Owasco St, Auburn, NY
4.2(9)•
$$ • Seafood
Charlie's Restaurant
1843 Empire Blvd, Webster, NY
4.4(114)•
$ • Seafood
Gio's Prime 26
26 Broadway, Rochester, NY
4.0(213)•
$$$$ • Seafood
Capitano Steak and Seafood
1400 Empire Blvd, Rochester, NY
3.6(34)•
Seafood
The Saucey Chef
1011 Culver Rd, Rochester, NY
4.4(33)•
Seafood
Debz Drive In Restaurant
934 County Rte 7, Hannibal, NY
4.5(2)•
Seafood
Chef King
655 Pittsford Victor Rd, Pittsford, NY
2.9(46)•
$ • Seafood
The Pies Guys Pizzeria
6 Baylis St, Oswego, NY
2.9(22)•
Seafood
Masters Seafood
524 Long Pond Rd, Rochester, NY
3.4(17)•
Seafood
Steger Haus
7171 N Geneva Rd, Sodus, NY
4.1(40)•
$$ • Venues & Event Spaces
Castaways
244 Lake Rd, Webster, NY
2.5(300)•
$$ • Seafood
Fairport Village Inn
103 N Main St, Fairport, NY
4.1(76)•
$$ • Seafood
Blue Water Grill
11 W Genesee St, Skaneateles, NY
3.4(358)•
$$ • Seafood
Monirae's Restaurant
688 County Rt 10, Pennellville, NY
3.3(12)•
$$ • Seafood
Rudy's Lakeside Drive-In
78 County Rte 89, Oswego, NY
3.9(235)•
$ • Seafood
Hedges 9 Mile Point
1290 Lake Rd, Webster, NY
3.1(148)•
$$$ • Seafood
Mohegan Manor
58 Oswego St, Baldwinsville, NY
3.6(80)•
$$$ • Seafood
Super Crab Juicy Seafood
1180 Jefferson Rd, Rochester, NY
4.1(79)•
Seafood
Hypnotic Creations
554 Chili Ave, Rochester, NY
Seafood
King Crab
102 Greece Ridge Center Dr, Rochester, NY
3.2(28)•
Seafood
Hooked Fish Market
333 Driving Park Ave, Rochester, NY
5.0(2)•
Seafood
King Fish Mkt
783 Plymouth Ave S, Rochester, NY
5.0(2)•
Seafood
Fried Fish Shack
826 Joseph Ave, Rochester, NY
5.0(2)•
Seafood
Perlo's
202 N Washington St, East Rochester, NY
3.3(237)•
$$ • Italian
Nick's Sea Breeze Inn
4581 Culver Rd, Rochester, NY
3.4(83)•
$$ • Seafood
Shamrock Jack's Irish Pub
4554 Culver Rd, Rochester, NY
4.0(130)•
$$ • Seafood
Skipper's Landing Restaurant
7061 Lake Bluff Rd, Wolcott, NY
4.1(65)•
$$ • Seafood
The Rock Shrimp Company
4775 Lake Ave, Rochester, NY
2.0(13)•
$$ • Seafood
Velvet Belly
3 Rochester Public Market, Rochester, NY
4.1(108)•
$$$ • Seafood
The Porterhouse Steak Scotch And Seafood
400 Packetts Lndg, Fairport, NY
3.4(131)•
$$$ • Seafood
Hidden Fish
7 Fennell St, Skaneateles, NY
4.0(30)•
Seafood
The Landing
85 Glasgow St, Clyde, NY
3.6(5)•
Seafood
Davies Seafood
395 Stone Rd, Greece, NY
3.1(60)•
$ • Seafood
Bayberry Fish Cove
7608 Oswego Rd, Liverpool, NY
4.0(28)•
$ • Seafood
Shaka
664 Eastview Mall, Victor, NY
3.8(4)•
Seafood
Condado Bar & Grill
2260 Clifford Ave, Rochester, NY
3.5(4)•
Seafood
Dunn's at the Heights
7030 Bayview Dr, Sodus Point, NY
5.0(2)•
American
Parker's on Fall
86-88 Fall St, Seneca Falls, NY
3.9(203)•
$$ • Burgers
