Claim your business to update business information, customize this listing, and more!
Black Otter Supper Club Giftly
A beautiful gift card alternative for Black Otter Supper Club
Gift Amount
Gift Design
100% satisfaction guarantee
Gift Tips
- Plan for a wait during busy dinner hours, since this supper club is a popular stop and the bar area is a comfortable place to relax first.
- Try the prime rib if you want the signature meal experience, especially the queen or king cut for a generous portion.
- Ask about the salad bar setup so you can enjoy the fresh, made-to-order style that many guests appreciate.
- Order a classic Wisconsin Old Fashioned to go with dinner and get the full supper club feel.
- Try the French onion soup or clam chowder as a warm start before the main course.
- Ask about the seafood and chicken specials, since options like haddock, whitefish, smothered chicken, and ribeye all get strong feedback.
- Go hungry, since the portions are generous and many guests leave with leftovers.
- If you like hearty sides, look for options like cheesy bacon mashed potatoes, potato wedges, or the baked potato with sour cream.
Click here to send a gift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to use it at Black Otter Supper Club.
Price$$
AmbienceCasual
Hours
Tuesday-Thursday, Sunday: 4PM-8:30PMFriday: 4PM-9PMSaturday: 3PM-9PM
Black Otter Supper Club is a casual American restaurant in Hortonville, Wisconsin. It offers a classic supper club experience that draws diners looking for a hearty dinner and a comfortable place to gather.
- Ambiance: Black Otter Supper Club has a casual, classic supper club feel in Hortonville, WI. The space can get busy, but it still feels warm and welcoming, with a lively bar area and a relaxed dining room.
- Cuisine: This American restaurant is known for hearty supper club fare, especially prime rib, steaks, fish, and chicken. Guests can also enjoy a fresh soup and salad bar, along with traditional sides and drinks.
- Highlights: The restaurant stands out for its large portions, organized service flow, and strong old-fashioned drink menu. Many diners also mention the friendly staff and the dependable quality of the meal from start to finish.
The restaurant is a popular choice for date nights, birthdays, and family dinners. Its no-reservation approach and busy pace can mean a wait, but the bar area gives guests a place to settle in before seating.
Black Otter is especially well known for generous portions and a meal format that feels true to Wisconsin supper clubs. With steak, seafood, and traditional sides on the menu, it gives visitors a chance to enjoy a filling dinner with a familiar local style.
The staff helps keep service moving even when the dining room is full, which adds to the restaurant's strong reputation. For guests who enjoy a classic supper club outing, Black Otter delivers a steady and memorable experience.
Customer Reviews
My wife and I went to the Black Otter for our anniversary. It was our first time there. When we arrived we checked in and were given a number. We sat at... read review
Was so excited to go here for a great meal
Unfortunately, that was not the case!!
Very, very disappointed again!!
The ribeye was more than half fat!
The... read review
Cannot understand why the parking lot is always full. Terrible food. Very basis salad bar had 3 people working it with a tip jar out. My steak looked like... read review
Matthew V.
06/22/2026
06/22/2026Shani Q.
08/08/2026
08/08/2026April F.09/12/2026
09/12/2026Great Alternatives
Buy a Gift & Greeting Card for Charlie's Drive-In: Charlie's Drive-In in Hortonville is a beloved local eatery that serves up delicious classic American fare with a side of nostalgia.
The Giftly Advantage
With Giftly you strike a perfect balance, the thoughtfulness of a Black Otter Supper Club gift card with the flexibility of money.
- Easy to buy online. Have it delivered now or later
- Send it with a personalized greeting card
- 3 easy ways for your recipient to redeem the gift
100% satisfaction guaranteed
No wasted balance
Easy to customize
How it works
- You customize a giftGift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to use it at Black Otter Supper Club. Delivered in a personalized greeting card.
- They receive the giftGifts can be sent by email, SMS*, mail or you can print it yourself.
- They enjoy it!They redeem the gift on our website and choose to deposit the funds in their bank account, Paypal account or to have a Visa / Mastercard Gift Card mailed to them.
Top Related Gifts
More Nearby Businesses
Whistlers Knoll
W9595 County Road Jj, Hortonville, WI
3.8(5)•
Wineries
Machine Shed Restaurant
220 Fox River Dr, Appleton, WI
3.5(201)•
$$ • American
Anduzzi's Sports Club - Howard
2555 Lineville Rd, Green Bay, WI
3.1(53)•
$$ • American
Redwood Inn
3230 Main St, Green Bay, WI
3.5(97)•
$$ • American
Greene's Pour House
134 W Wisconsin Ave, Neenah, WI
3.7(175)•
$$ • American
Schmitty's Oar House Bar & Grill
N7044 Winnebago Dr, Fond Du Lac, WI
4.4(137)•
$$ • American
The Bar - Holmgren Way
2001 Holmgren Way, Green Bay, WI
2.9(94)•
$$ • American
Kropp's Supper Club
4570 Shawano Ave, Green Bay, WI
4.3(78)•
$$ • American
Norton's of Green Lake
380 South Lawson Dr, Green Lake, WI
3.5(118)•
$$ • American
D2 Sport Pub Stadium District
788 Armed Forces Dr, Green Bay, WI
2.9(30)•
$$ • American
Pullmans At Trolley Square
619 S Old Oneida St, Appleton, WI
3.2(174)•
$$ • American
Sidelines Sports Pub And Grill
W6278 Greenville Dr, Greenville, WI
2.9(14)•
$$ • American
ATW Restaurant
Outagamie County Regional Airport, Appleton, WI
3.0(2)•
$$ • American
GameDay Sports Bar
N225 Stoney Brook Rd, Appleton, WI
2.8(48)•
$$ • American
MJ's Supper Club
W8326 County Rd Mm, Hortonville, WI
3.8(28)•
Supper Clubs
Waters Supperclub
815 W Wolf River Ave, New London, WI
3.9(35)•
$$ • American
Batley's Grill & Bar
1010 Cameron Way, Neenah, WI
3.5(85)•
$$ • American
Krolls West Restaurant
1990 S Ridge Rd, Green Bay, WI
2.8(370)•
$$ • American
Angel's Restaurant
1401 E John St, Appleton, WI
3.7(37)•
$$ • American
Waverly Beach
N8770 Firelane 1, Menasha, WI
2.5(137)•
$$ • American
Wendt's On the Lake
N9699 Lakeshore Dr, Van Dyne, WI
4.0(101)•
$$ • American
White Dog Black Cat Cafe
201 S Broadway, Green Bay, WI
4.2(283)•
$$ • American
Red Rooster Cafe and Catering
237 S Cecil St, Bonduel, WI
4.0(32)•
$$ • American
Mineshaft Oshkosh
2041 South Koeller St, Oshkosh, WI
2.8(155)•
$$ • American
Hagemeister Park
325 N Washington St, Green Bay, WI
2.9(329)•
$$ • American
Denny's Restaurant
3470 West College Ave, Appleton, WI
2.6(47)•
$$ • American
Hahn-a-Lula Resort
8861 S Wolf River Rd, Fremont, WI
2.8(23)•
$$ • American
Michiels Bar & Grill
1100 Appleton Rd, Menasha, WI
2.8(46)•
$$ • American
Patti's Place
116 W Main St, Hortonville, WI
3.3(6)•
Restaurants
WeatherVane Restaurant
186 Main St, Menasha, WI
4.4(151)•
$$ • American
Pine Tree Supper Club
E8095 State Rd 54, New London, WI
3.6(46)•
$$ • American
Holidays Pub & Grill
1395 W American Dr, Neenah, WI
3.8(55)•
$$ • American
Gabe’s Wisconsin Kitchen and Tavern
1160 N Westhaven Dr, Oshkosh, WI
3.8(59)•
$$ • American
Goose Blind Grill & Bar
512 Gold St, Green Lake, WI
3.2(112)•
$$ • American
Fox Harbor
348 S Washington St, Green Bay, WI
3.8(169)•
$$ • American
Mackinaws Grill & Spirits
2925 Voyager Dr, Green Bay, WI
3.6(187)•
$$ • American
Dockside Tavern
425 Nebraska St, Oshkosh, WI
2.7(108)•
$$ • American
Taverne in the Sky
1950 South Ridge Rd, Green Bay, WI
3.4(136)•
$$ • American
Simpson's Restaurant
222 S Main St, Waupaca, WI
3.8(62)•
$$ • American
Good Company
110 N Richmond, Appleton, WI
2.9(161)•
$$ • American
Sulten Belly
220 S Main St, Waupaca, WI
4.8(25)•
$$ • American
Jeff's On Rugby
1005 Rugby St, Oshkosh, WI
3.6(34)•
$$ • American
