Asterisk Supper Club Giftly

Asterisk Supper Club brings a distinctly Uptown Westerville sensibility to dining: part cocktail bar, part tea room, and thoroughly comfortable. Housed among floor-to-ceiling bookshelves and anchored by an 1890 hand-carved bar, the space blends vintage charm with a relaxed, urban polish. Guests settle into the glow of antique chandeliers as time seems to slow—perfect for lingering over an afternoon tea or a well-made nightcap.

The kitchen leans into from-scratch comfort with a modern touch, offering familiar dishes executed with care and a few playful twists. Think richly layered tomato basil soup, crisp truffle fries with garlicky aioli, and shareable favorites like mushroom toast. Dinner might turn toward classics—meatloaf with silky sides, a well-seared steak with a Burgundy mushroom demi, or a seasonal feature—while the pastry case tempts with light, pretty desserts and a cinnamon roll–topped apple pie that nods to nostalgia without feeling heavy-handed.

Afternoon tea is a signature experience. Guests select teas by mood and flavor, then build tiers of delicate sandwiches, scones, and petite sweets. It’s as customizable as it is charming, making it a smart pick for celebrations, bridal showers, or a leisurely catch‑up with friends. When evening arrives, the bar shines with thoughtful, spirit-forward cocktails—Old Fashioneds kissed with smoke, vibrant gin creations with fresh herbs, and classics served in retro glassware. Live music appears on select nights, adding an easy warmth to the room.

Service is attentive and personable, the pace unhurried. Whether stopping in for a cozy solo tea, gathering a group at the community table, or settling into a date-night booth, Asterisk Supper Club makes each visit feel considered. It’s the kind of place that turns simple moments—sharing a pot of tea, splitting a dessert, discovering a new favorite cocktail—into small rituals worth repeating in Westerville.